What Makes a Good Decaf Coffee?

Why Decaf Is Worth Your Attention

Decaffeinated coffee has often been treated as the underdog of the coffee world, dismissed as bland or lacking complexity. In fact, for decaffeination centres often decaf is the byproduct of the process… Things are changing though and decaf is finally having its moment. Innovations in processing methods, a growing focus on sustainability, and an appreciation for high-quality beans have transformed decaf into an exciting and diverse option for coffee lovers.

It’s not just for people sensitive to caffeine but also for coffee drinkers who are health conscious or want to keep drinking throughout the day without risking a restless sleep. Specialty drinkers have moved on from death before decaf and are after quality decaf options. So, what exactly makes a good decaf coffee?

Why Are So Many Decafs Bland?

The idea that decaf coffee is bland isn’t just perception—it’s rooted in the science of how decaffeination affects coffee beans. Removing caffeine is a complex process that can strip away other compounds responsible for flavour, aroma, and body.

Chemical Changes in Decaf Coffee:

1. Loss of key compounds:
   Decaffeination leads to the extraction of water-soluble compounds such as:

   • Carbohydrates: Decaffeinated coffee beans lose about 16% of total carbohydrates during the process, as shown in recent studies. These carbohydrates are precursors for the Maillard reaction, which creates rich flavours during roasting. This reduction limits the potential for complex flavour development in decaf coffee.

   • Trigonelline: Responsible for coffee’s sweetness and bitterness, trigonelline is reduced by an average of 25% during decaffeination. This compound contributes to the formation of aromatic compounds like pyrazines during roasting, which are crucial for nutty and roasted flavours. Decaffeinated coffee has significantly lower levels of pyrazines as a result.

2. Higher chlorogenic acid content:
   Interestingly, decaffeinated green coffee beans can have relatively higher levels of chlorogenic acids due to the selective loss of other water-soluble components like carbohydrates and trigonelline. However, chlorogenic acids degrade during roasting, forming lactones and bitter compounds. This means dark-roasted decaf may still retain astringent notes despite its lower complexity.

Volatile Compounds and Aroma:

The most significant differences between regular and decaf coffee are found in their volatile compounds:

• Pyrazines: The concentration of 3-ethyl-2,5-dimethylpyrazine, a key contributor to nutty and roasted aromas, is 58% lower in decaffeinated coffee than in regular coffee. This deficiency explains why decaf often tastes less nutty and sweet.

• Guaiacol and Furfural: Guaiacol, associated with smoky and bitter notes, is less affected by decaffeination, but furfural, which contributes sweetness, is significantly reduced.

In summary, the soaking and extraction steps of decaffeination alter the balance of essential precursors and volatile compounds, leading to a flatter flavour profile. Those compounds play a role in the way coffee reacts when roasted, its aroma, and its flavour.

It goes without saying that the more exciting the coffee is at the start of the process, the more likely it is to remain tasty after decaffeination. Unfortunately, traditionally lower quality coffee has been used for decaffeination and that results in a cup of disappointment.

However, using higher quality beans for decaf, advancements in decaffeination techniques. and experimental processes are aiming to address these challenges.

Why Are Most Top Decafs Colombian?

This is a question I get a lot when I talk about decaf. Colombia is synonymous with high-quality decaf coffee at the moment, and this dominance is no coincidence. Several unique factors contribute to Colombia’s reputation for exceptional decaf:

1. Local decaffeination facilities: Colombia is home to Descafecol, a world-class decaffeination plant in Manizales. The presence of such facilities allows coffee producers to decaffeinate beans at origin, significantly reducing transportation costs and environmental impact. Producers can maintain control over quality while minimising carbon footprints.

2. Abundance of sugarcane: Colombia’s thriving sugarcane industry makes the sugarcane ethyl acetate (EA) decaffeination process both affordable and sustainable. Ethyl acetate is derived from fermented sugarcane, providing a natural solvent that selectively removes caffeine while preserving flavour.

3. Ideal coffee-growing conditions: Colombia’s unique microclimates produce Arabica beans with bright acidity, balanced sweetness, and mild flavour—all of which withstand the decaffeination process better than other coffee origins.

4. Experimental coffee processes: Colombian producers are well known for employing novel methods of coffee processing. A few of them have recently started decaffeinating experimentally processed coffee or even attempting new methods of decaffeination (e.g. mucilage EA by Los Nogales)

5. Empowering smallholders: Many Colombian coffee farms are small and family-owned. Having access to local decaffeination facilities ensures that farmers retain more value in the supply chain while supporting their livelihoods.

A Matter of Taste

Taste in coffee is deeply personal, and decaf is no exception. James Hoffmann’s Decaf Project demonstrated just how varied individual responses to decaf coffee can be.

1. The Decaf Project:
   Hoffmann tested coffees processed through various decaffeination methods—EA, Swiss Water, and CO₂—with diverse tasters. Interestingly, in some preliminary surveys the EA-processed decaf received the highest average scores for body and sweetness, but individual preferences varied widely:

   • Some loved the EA method’s richness, while others found it overly sweet.

   • Swiss Water decaf appealed to those seeking clarity but was criticised for its simplicity.
     

2. Personal preferences:
   I personally lean towards fruity, lighter roast profiles that highlight rare and unique processing flavours. However, others may prefer nutty, chocolatey notes with a deeper roast—proof that there’s no one-size-fits-all when it comes to decaf.

The Funkier, the Better: Why More Processed Decafs Are Delicious

Innovation in coffee processing has brought forward experimental approaches that enhance flavour—particularly in decaf coffees. Funkier, more processed beans can make for a more delicious cup:

1. Anaerobic fermentation: A game-changer for flavour complexity: Anaerobic fermentation, carried out in sealed, oxygen-free environments, promotes microbial activity that metabolises sugars and acids in unique ways. This process results in the production of organic acids (e.g., lactic acid, citric acid, and malic acid) and volatile compounds that enhance coffee’s fruity, wine-like, and caramel notes. A study by Jimenez and colleagues (2023) revealed that anaerobic fermentation using Torulospora delbrueckii and Saccharomyces cerevisiae produced coffees with highly desirable sensory profiles, including citrus, caramel, and chocolate notes, while achieving specialty coffee scores above 85. This method is not only useful for caffeinated coffee but could enhance decaf coffee by compensating for lost aroma and flavour compounds.

2. Yeast Inoculation: Adding yeast starter cultures during anaerobic fermentation allows producers to target specific flavour outcomes. This is a method used in some of the decafs by Wilton Benitez. For example:

   • Torulospora delbrueckii was found to enhance citrus and honey flavours, while Saccharomyces cerevisiae emphasised caramel and chocolate notes.

   • These controlled fermentations achieved higher concentrations of desirable volatile compounds like pyrazines, esters, and furans—key contributors to coffee’s roasted, nutty, and fruity aromas (Jimenez et al., 2023).

3. Re-Fermentation: reviving flavour after decaffeination
   Re-fermentation, where decaffeinated beans are subjected to a secondary fermentation process, is emerging as a promising way to restore or enhance flavour in decaf coffee in the lab. Recent studies have demonstrated the potential of natural ingredients in this process (I wrote about this in detail previously):

   • Purple sweet potato and passion fruit pulp: Used as a fermentation substrate, this mixture increased chlorogenic acid levels and preserved acidity in decaf coffee, helping to balance flavour.

   • Watermelon rinds and sugar: This method produced decaf beans with specialty coffee scores (robusta!), characterised by notes of sweet potato, brown sugar, and herbal tones.

4. Decaffeination methods as processing: The sugarcane EA process adds subtle sweetness and caramel tones to decaf coffee. By pairing this method with beans naturally high in acidity producers can achieve decafs with more interesting flavour profiles.

Conclusion

So, what makes a good decaf coffee? For me, it’s the combination of thoughtful decaffeination methods, innovative processing techniques, respect for the bean’s origin, and careful roasting. As we’ve seen, decaf coffee has long been considered a byproduct—something less than its caffeinated counterpart—but the narrative is changing.

Advances in decaffeination techniques, such as sugarcane EA, are preserving more of the bean’s natural complexity. Experimental methods like anaerobic fermentation, yeast inoculation, and co-fermentation are pushing the boundaries of what decaf can taste like. These techniques restore or enhance flavours lost during decaffeination, creating decaf coffees that rival—or even surpass—the complexity of regular coffee.

Yet, at the heart of it all lies the simple fact that coffee is deeply personal. Taste varies widely from one drinker to the next, and what works for one may not work for you. Whether you lean toward fruity, lightly roasted decafs or prefer rich, nutty, chocolatey profiles, there’s never been a better time to explore the diverse world of decaf coffee.

Decaf coffee is no longer just an option for the caffeine-sensitive—it’s for anyone who wants to enjoy exceptional coffee all day long without the buzz. With its rising quality and innovation, decaf has earned its moment in the spotlight. Happy brewing!

---

If you have some time to kill and want to read some of the research mentioned in this article check out the papers below:

Aulia, N. A., Bastian, F., & Asfar, M. (2023, September). Flavor enhancement of decaffeinated robusta beans re-fermentation using a mucilage analog of the blend of watermelon albedo (Citrullus vulagris Schard) and sucrose. In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science (Vol. 1230, No. 1, p. 012174). IOP Publishing.

Jimenez, E. J. M., Martins, P. M. M., de Oliveira Vilela, A. L., Batista, N. N., da Rosa, S. D. V. F., Dias, D. R., & Schwan, R. F. (2023). Influence of anaerobic fermentation and yeast inoculation on the viability, chemical composition, and quality of coffee. Food Bioscience, 51, 102218.

Park, H., Noh, E., Kim, M., & Lee, K. G. (2024). Analysis of volatile and nonvolatile compounds in decaffeinated and regular coffee prepared under various roasting conditions. Food Chemistry, 435, 137543.

Sinaga, H. L. R., Bastian, F., & Syarifuddin, A. (2021, July). Effect of decaffeination and re-fermentation on level of caffeine, chlorogenic acid and total acid in green bean robusta coffee. In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science (Vol. 807, No. 2, p. 022069). IOP Publishing.